Miami Theaters and Artists Dominate Carbonell Awards

Actors’ Playhouse production of Man of La Mancha

By Bill Hirschman

Miami-based theater companies overran 17 of the 20 competitive Carbonell Award categories announced during a decidedly family gala Monday night nicknamed “theater prom.” 

The moving Man of La Mancha from Actors’ Playhouse at the Miracle Theatre in Coral Gables was the source of six awards including Outstanding Musical. Miami New Drama’s world premiere of The Zionists claimed four including Outstanding New Work.

M Ensemble based in Miami, one of the nation’s oldest standing Black companies, took one; GableStage and Zoetic Stage in Miami each produced three.

Elsewhere, The Wick Theatre and Costume Museum in Boca Raton took one and Island City Stage in Wilton Manors hosted two.

For the second year in a row, the production was noticeably celebratory at FAU‘s University Theatre in Boca Raton, one year prior to its 50th anniversary.

Lindsay Corey

Among the notable awards, veteran actress Lindsay Corey won two: Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Lead Female Role in a Musical as the mother of a child actress who becomes a diva herself in Island City Stage’s Ruthless; and Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Female Role in a Musical as the protagonist’s first wife in Merrily We Roll Along at Zoetic Stage.

The other recipients were:

  • Outstanding Production, Play; Harry Clarke; GableStage
  • Outstanding Production, Musical; Man of La Mancha; Actors’ Playhouse at the Miracle Theatre

The Zionists (Photo by Morgan Sophia Photography)

  • Outstanding New Work; The Zionists by S. Asher Gelman; Miami New Drama
  • Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Lead Female Role, Play; Jeni Hacker, The Mother; Zoetic Stage
  • Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Lead Male Role, Play; Mark H. Dold; Harry Clarke; GableStage
  • Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Male Role, Play; Michael McKeever; The Inheritance, Part 1; Zoetic Stage
  • Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Female Role, Play; Sheena O. Murray; Searching for Willie Lynch; M Ensemble
  • Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Lead Male Role, Musical; E.L. Losada; Man of La Mancha; Actors’ Playhouse

E.L. Losada

  • Outstanding Performance by an Actor in a Supporting Male Role, Musical; Jose Luaces (as Sancho Panza); Man of La Mancha; Actors Playhouse
  • Outstanding Direction, Play; Julianne Boyd; Harry Clarke; GableStage
  • Outstanding Direction, Musical; David Arisco, Man of La Mancha; Actors Playhouse, which marked his tenth Carbonell in his career.
  • Outstanding Music Direction; Bruce Barnes; Man of La Mancha; Actors Playhouse
  • Outstanding Costume Design; Ellis Tillman; Man of La Mancha; Actors Playhouse
  • Outstanding Scenic Design; Adam Koch; The Zionists; Miami New Drama
  • Outstanding Lighting Design; Solomon Weisbard; The Zionists; Miami New Drama
  • Outstanding Sound Design; Andy Cohen and Saloman Lerner; The Zionists; Miami New Drama
  • Outstanding Achievement of an Artistic Specialty; Bong Redila for illustration; Everything Beautiful Happens at Night; Island City Stage
  •   Outstanding Choreography; Sabrina Gail Lobner; The Cher Show; The Wick Theatre and Costume Museum

In addition to the 20 competitive award categories, nine Special Awards are nominated by members of the local theater community and selected by the nonprofit organization’s board of directors. A full list of all nominees can be found on this website at https://www.floridatheateronstage.com/news/list-of-2025-26-carbonell-nominations-and-awards-something-old-something-new/

Stuart Meltzer

The Carbonells’s highest recognition, the George Abbott Award for Outstanding Achievement in the Arts, given to Stuart Meltzer, founding Artistic Director of Zoetic Stage.

+ The Vinnette Carroll Award for outstanding achievement in advancing diversity, equality, and inclusion in South Florida Theatre to Our Fund Foundation.

+ The Charlie Cinnamon Award for outstanding support of South Florida Theatre and the Carbonell Awards to Michelle F. Solomon, editor and theater critic for ArtBurstmiami and miamiartzine.com.r

 + The Christine Dolen Award for outstanding debut to Ali Tallman, director of The 39 Steps for New City Players.

 + Ruth Foreman Award for outstanding contribution to the development of South Florida Theatre to Margaret M. Ledford, Artistic Director of City Theatre in Miami.

+  The Bill Hindman Award for career achievement by performing artists based in South Florida to actor, playwright and educator Elena Maria Garcia.

+  The Howard Kleinberg Award for outstanding contribution to the health and development of the arts in South Florida to educators inspiring the next generation: Gary Cadwallader (Palm Beach Dramaworks), Jairo Ontiveros (Adrienne Arsht Center for the Performing Arts of Miami-Dade County), and Lori Slade Sessions (South Florida Cappies).

+  The Jan McArt Award recognizing significant achievement by a small theatre to Brévo Theatre.

+ The Bill von Maurer Award for Theatrical Excellence honoring a theatre company that exemplifies excellence for the totality of its programming: productions, educational outreach, developmental programs, and audiences served to Island City Stage.

“More than 100 productions at 33 theaters were evaluated last season by a diverse group of nearly 50 judges representing all three participating counties (Broward, Miami-Dade, Palm Beach). On September 15, we announced 120 finalists from 40 different and diverse productions at 16 professional theaters,” says Carbonell Board President Gary Schweikhart.

The production was more fully-produced than in the past with a neon-tubed proscenium, a peppysfriot, lighting, a curved curtain backdrop, a 12-piece orchestra, choreography, students choristers and dancers.

Lou Tyrrell

The In Memoriam segment honored nine artists and supporters including icon Lou Tyrrell and Brevo Theatre’s Toddra Brunson who died late in the rehearsal for The Color Purple.

As part of the 2026 Carbonell Awards, $2,000 Jack Zink Memorial Student Scholarships were awarded to Sofia Bornia (Palm Beach County), Avery Garfinkel (Broward County), and Matthew Aidan Sanchez (Miami-Dade County). They also each received a bonus $1,000 scholarship from the new Hap Erstein Memorial Scholarship, named after the longtime theater reviewer and Carbonell judge.

In addition, for the first time, the three runners-up this year each received a $500 Hap Erstein Memorial Scholarship: Maya Beaufort (Miami-Dade County), Jay Hendrix Boegem (Broward County), and SkyLynn Silver (Palm Beach County).

The ceremony was written and overseen by Executive Producer and Director Andrew Kato, Producing Artistic Director/Chief Executive of the Maltz Jupiter Theatre, along with Producer Eloisa M. Ferrer, and Associate Producer and Musical Director Caryl Fantel from the Florida Atlantic University Department of Theatre and Dance.

The Carbonell Awards claim to “foster the artistic growth of professional theater in South Florida by celebrating the excellence and diversity of theater artists, providing educational scholarships, and building audience appreciation and civic pride by highlighting achievements of the theater community,” according to its website.

More than 33 professional theater companies in Broward, Miami-Dade and Palm Beach Counties participate in the awards process.

Along with New York’s Drama Desk and Chicago’s Joseph Jefferson Awards, the Carbonell Awards are among the nation’s oldest regional arts awards and predate others, including Washington, D.C.’s Helen Hayes Awards.

The Awards are named after the late Florida-based sculptor Manuel Carbonell, who designed the oval-shaped solid bronze and marble award.  Over nearly a half-century, the Carbonell family has donated more than $250,000 in awards.

Instead of individual award presenters, this year the job of presenting the honors went to the show’s four hosts: Alex Jorth, Joel Rodriguez, Lillie Eliza Thomas and Gaby Tortoledo.

As usual, music was integral to the program. The musical numbers were chosen before the nominees were calculated, so some numbers were not connected to nominees. Played by a 12-piece orchestra led by Associate Producer and Musical Director Caryl Fantel from the Florida Atlantic University Department of Theatre and Dance. They were all re-orchestrated, some with an intentional  Miami Sound Machine-like flavor.

The evening opened with “From Miami to Jupiter,” with lyrics by Andrew Kato, and music by Joshua Lubben, performed by Alexander Blanco, Carbonell Awards Dancers, FAU Musical Theatre Vocal Ensemble, and the Carbonell Awards Orchestra.

Even the rules were delivered by the hosts in a musical spoof written by Kato and Andy Nevala.

Every musical performance were genuine showstoppers:  “I’m Here” from The Color Purple performed by  Brooklyn Miller who was in the Brevo Theatre production; “You Learn” from Jagged Little Pill performed by Emily van Vliet Perea and Louis Martinez; “Waving Through A Window” from Dear Evan Hansen performed by Logan Clinger who starred in the Actors’ Playhouse production; “Old Friends” from Merrily We Roll Along performed by Kalen Edean, Alex Jorth and Joline Mujica; “Great Balls of Fire” from Million Dollar Quartet performed by Sean McGibbon from the Maltz Jupiter Theatre production; the memoriam section featured “The Place Where Lost Things Go” from Mary Poppins Returns performed by the Carbonell Orchestra and the FAU Musical Theatre Vocal Ensemble, and the  “Finale” from The Cher Show performed by Catherine Ariale, Kristin Rose Kelleher, Ella Perez from The Wick Theatre production.

This entry was posted in General, News and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.