New City Players’ An Enemy Of The People: Passionate, Beautiful And Eiveting.

Community chaos in New City Players; An Enemy of the People with (from left) Peter Alexander Pera, David H. Hepburn, Ben Sandomir, Chad Raven (Photo by Kevin Ondorza)

By Jan Sjostrom

If An Enemy of the People had sprung from Hollywood the doctor at the center of the story would be an intrepid underdog who blows the whistle on the fat-cat elite and wins.

Instead, the story came from the mind of Norwegian Henrik Ibsen, the 19th century “father of modern drama,” whose trailblazing realistic plays tackled thorny social issues that continue to challenge us today.

Among the evergreen issues the play confronts are environmental pollution, economic versus moral priorities, individual responsibility, and threats to a functional democracy.  Not bad for a play that debuted in 1882.

If that makes it sound like a boring textbook, New City Players’ production at Island City Stage in Wilton Manors dispels that notion. It is passionate, beautiful and riveting.

The Florida premiere is directed by Ali Tallman, who obviously thought deeply about how to stage the story so that it spoke to a contemporary audience without watering down its tough message.

She chose Amy Herzog’s version of the play, used in its highly successful 2024 Broadway revival, which pared Ibsen’s five acts to two and made other tweaks to modernize the show. The show blends drama with humor, which flashes naturally in the ways that characters relate to one another.

The cast doesn’t just act its roles, it lives them – down to the subtlest gesture, the most telling facial expression and the precise tone of voice – so that the story feels like it’s unfolding in real time.

Except that real life rarely gets a boost from superb craftsmanship like that of scenic designer Michael McClain, sound designer Andrea Guardo-Cuao, lighting designer Desirae Merritt and costume designer Casey Sacco.

They create the play’s world with a stunning set, stirring string music, thunderous portents, beautifully tailored period costumes and lighting that ranges from buttery warmth to Dickensian darkness.

The story is set in the early 1880s in a small spa town on the Norwegian coast.  It opens on a set dominated by a multi-paned wall of windows looking out on a vista of misty, pine-clad mountains. Walls resembling wood carvings frame the stage like giant trees. Sounds of surf and seagulls conjure up the nearby ocean.

Dr. Thomas Stockmann, medical officer for the town’s baths, has made a shocking discovery. The baths, which are the catalyst for the town’s economic revival, are being fed by contaminated water that is making customers sick.  He’s convinced the town will be grateful to him for uncovering the danger and galvanized to fix the problem.

At first that seems to be the case, when Hovstad, the town newspaper’s editor, his assistant, Billing, and Aslaksen (David H. Hepburn), a leading businessman, pledge to back him.

Hovstad (Peter Alexander Pera) and Billing (Chad Raven) are drawn as much by the doctor’s good-looking but independent daughter Petra (Marla Lopez) as they are by the opportunity to hitch their left-leaning political rhetoric to the doctor’s cause.

But their enthusiasm evaporates when the doctor’s brother Peter, who’s the mayor and chairman of the baths’ board, alerts them to the danger that fixing the pipes will pose to their wallets. In no time flat, the hero of the hour becomes “an enemy of the people.”

One of the techniques Tallman uses to imprint this progression on the audience is the photographic tableau.  The show opens with cast members lined up behind the glass wall with the doctor and his daughter in the middle, as though posed for a formal picture in the 19th century.  There’s even a burst of light like that of a flash bulb.

Midway through, when the doctor has been cast out of the community for his unwelcome news, he stands alone in chilly light behind the wall, as though shivering in the cold.

The play concludes with another tableau behind the glass, but this time the doctor and his daughter are excluded. They’re comforting one another within the warm interior of the house. There’s another flash of light. The “photo” freezes the moment, emphasizing their expulsion from the community.

The doctor, nimbly portrayed by Ben Sandomir, sours from an open-hearted, hospitable optimist to a bitter rebel who lashes out at his neighbors and resists all efforts to silence him.

The doctor stands alone, except for Petra and the apolitical ship captain Horster (Timothy Mark Davis), the only one to extend a helping hand. His miserly father-in-law, played by Michael Gioia, sporting wild white hair and a beard, tries to use him as a pawn in a get-rich-quick scheme.

The long-simmering rivalry between the doctor and his brother is as much to blame for the doctor’s downfall as short-sighted economic self-interest.

The mayor, in a vulnerable yet ruthless portrayal by Ryan Didato, is proud of his position and knows how to hang on to it. He considers the doctor an improvident hothead while the doctor dismisses him as a corrupt politician. At one point in the story the doctor steals the mayor’s beribboned hat and mocks his self-important brother while the furious mayor chases after him.

Both men have legitimate priorities.  That’s one of the show’s strengths. But the frayed bond between them is not strong enough to bring them together.

The show is part of New City Players’ season celebrating the United States’ 250th birthday. Each play “examines a community at the breaking point,” according to the company’s website. Each asks the question “What holds us together when we’re pushed apart?”

The company’s production of An Enemy of the People reminds us of what can happen when a community fails to answer that question.

New City Players’ production of An Enemy of the People will be at Island City Stage, 2304 N. Dixie Highway, Wilton Manors through Nov. 29. 8 p.m. Friday and Saturday; 3 p.m. Saturday and Sunday. The show runs 2 hours plus a 15-minute intermission. Tickets cost $40-$45. For tickets call (954) 376-6114 or visit newcityplayers.org.

This entry was posted in Performances, Reviews and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Time limit is exhausted. Please reload the CAPTCHA.